Season 1 The Boyfriend / The Tender Trap
Season 2 Guest In The House / Gypsy / Come Blow Your Horn
Season 3 Ten Little Indians / L'il Abner / Little Mary Sunshine
Season 4 Come Back Little Sheba /Arsenic and Old Lace / Never Too Late
Season 5 Charlie's Aunt / Finian's Rainbow

Season 6 The Trysting Place/ Visitor From Mamaroneck / The Mousetrap / Barefoot in the Park
Season 7 Scrooge
Season 8 Witness for the Prosecution / The White Sheep of the Family / Small Hotel / Cinderella
Season 9 Boeing Boeing / Butterflies are Free / Beware the Quickly Who
Season 10 Night Must Fall / The Secretary Bird / What the Butler Saw

Season 11The Sound of Music / No Sex Please We're British
Season 12 Bus Stop / The Hand That Cradles the Rock / The King and I
Season 13 The Rattle of a Simple Man / An Evening with Stephen Leacock / How the Other Half Loves
Season 14 Blithe Spirit / Generations / The Shaping
Season 15 The Show Must Go On

Season 16 The Odd Couple / Mr. Scrooge / Ladies in Retirement / Night Of January 16th
Season 17 Dracula / Scrooge / Lovers and Other Strangers / You Can't Take It With You
Season 18 Deathtrap / Three Christmas Plays / Spinoff / Luxury Cruise
Season 19 The Ginger Bread Lady / Mr. Scrooge / Catch Me If You Can / Veronica's Room / The Tomorrow Box
Season 20 The Last Real Summer / The Mystery of the Oak Island Treasure / Angel of Death / The Tomorrow Box

Season 21 Planned Season: I Ought to be in Pictures / Mark of Cain / The Gin Game / Sinners - No season held: cancelled while we converted the play house to a theatre

Season 21 Agnes of God / Play On! / Dangerous Corner / Sinners
Season 22 Sleuth / Silent Night, Lonely Night / A Very Modest Orgy / Jennie's Story
Season 23 Uncle Corbett Lives in the Attic / Alice in Wonderland / The Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 / 'night Mother
Season 24 I'll Be Back Before Midnight / The Mumberley Inheritance / Jitters / Another Season's Promise
Season 25 House of Frankenstein /Little Red Riding Hood / The Last Real Summer / The Shadow Walkers

Season 26 Mark of Cain / Mr. Scrooge / Beyond Therapy / The Melville Boys
Season 27 Arsenic and Old Lace / The Emperor's New Clothes / Medium for Murder / The Hand That Cradles the Rock
Season 28 Twelve Angry Jurors / The Mystery of the Oak Island Treasure / Marvin's Room / Windfall
Season 29 Veronica's Room / Alice in Wonderland / Ned Durango Comes to Big Oak / Opening Night
Season 30 Witness for the Prosecution / Scrooge / It Runs In the Family / Sinners

Season 31 Doctor Death / Cinderella / Cookin' With Gus / California Suite
Season 32 To Die For / A Christmas Carol / The Nerd / Night of January 16th
Season 33 How Could You Mrs. Dick / Little Red Riding Hood / The Foursome / Play On!
Season 34 Misery / Little Women / Picasso at the Lapin Agile / Flaming Idiots
Season 35 Angel of Death / The Christmas Story / The Wild Guys / To Forgive Divine / Chicken Coop and the Mating Dance

Season 36 The Chronicler / Are You Nuts / Laughter on the 23rd Floor / Patches / Cash on Delivery
Season 37 Wrong for Each Other / Cinderella / The Mousetrap / Swan Song / Beyond Therapy
Season 38 Cookin' with Gus / Mr. Scrooge / Musical Comedy Murders of 1940 / The Importance of Being Earnest / Salt-Water Moon
Season 39 Getting Away with Murder / Miracle on 34th Street / That Darn Plot / The Senator Wore Pantyhose / The Golden Years

Season 40 The Diary of Anne Frank / The Somewhat True Tale of Robin Hood / Barefoot in the Park / John Lennon and Me / Maggie's Getting Married

Season 41 Death Trap / The Homecoming / The Odd Couple / I Hate Hamlet / The Affections of May

Season 42 Kitchen Witches / Charlotte's Web / Here on the Flight Path / Lend Me a Tenor / On Golden Pond

Season 43 The Long Weekend / A Christmas Carol / That Summer / Moon over Buffalo / Neighbourhood Crime Watch